EARTH
3Nightmare Scorpion
ATK:
900
DEF:
800
View:
1833
''A creature that generates nightmares to haunt an opponent, it attacks with four poisonous tails.''
Nightmare Scorpion — Power Evaluation
Final Score: 30 ± 5 · Confidence: Medium
- Intrinsic: 32 · Deck: 28 · Meta: provisional
- Primary role: Material body
Why it scores here
Nightmare Scorpion is a bare Level-3 Normal Monster with no effect text and minimal practical utility. While it serves as a generic EARTH Insect body usable for Synchro, XYZ, or Fusion material, the combination of low ATK (900), bricky opening-hand presence, and lack of value generation severely limits its power. The evidence shows it appearing only in 2 old casual decks as 1-ofs, with zero recorded combo appearances, indicating it functions purely as filler rather than a synergy driver.
Axis scores
| Axis | Score | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Accessibility | 25 | Level-3 Normal Monsters are not searchable by modern archetypes and sit dead in hand most turns; appears in only 2 decks as 1-of in each (observed: deck data shows 2 decks, 1 copy per deck, not a core piece) |
| Combo & Conversion | 8 | It has no effect text and zero combo board appearances; unable to generate board progression on its own (verified: description is flavor text only, combo data.total combos = 0) |
| Resource Economy | 12 | Summoning it consumes a normal summon with no card advantage, draw, or GY refuel in return (inferred: Normal Monster with no effect, no search or recursion) |
| Effect & Interaction | 0 | It is a bare Normal Monster with no negation, removal, or disruption capability whatsoever (verified: no effect in card description) |
| Material Utility | 40 | It is a valid Level-3 EARTH Insect body usable as Synchro/Fusion material, though Level-3 is awkward for modern synergy lines and inferior to specialized bodies (inferred: generic material pool, not optimized for any specific archetype) |
| Resilience & Flexibility | 15 | Once on field it has low ATK (900) making it trivial to remove or run over; no protection or recursion available (verified: 900 ATK stat; inferred: Normal Monster with no effect) |
| Deck-Building Efficiency | 30 | Running a 900 ATK Normal Monster with no effect inefficiently consumes deck slots; the 2 decks run it as filler, not as a core synergy piece (observed: deck data shows Watt 1 deck and Hole 1 deck, both Aug 2023, all partners are old generic cards) |
Calculation
Weight profile: Primary role: Material body / Normal. Intrinsic ≈ 32, Deck ≈ 28, Meta = provisional. Modifiers: none. Final formula: 0.40*Intrinsic + 0.60*Deck
Strengths
- Generic EARTH Insect body usable for Synchro, XYZ, and Fusion material
- Can be normal summoned without prerequisites; no activation cost
Weaknesses
- No effect text — purely a body with zero inherent value generation
- Low ATK (900) trivially removed or run over by modern monsters
- Bricky in opening hand; consumes normal summon without board progression
- Not searchable by modern archetype searchers; must be drawn
- No recursion, protection, or recovery tools
Counters / choke points
- Combat-based removal easily dispatches 900 ATK body
- Any disruption to normal summon or tribute activation
- Modern replacement bodies with better stats and effects
Best use
Generic Level-3 Insect body for tribute costs or Synchro/Fusion material. Decks: Watt (as tribute fodder for Trap Hole effects), Hole (as filler tribute), Casual Insect-themed decks. Suggested copies: 1.
Evidence & gaps
- Verified: Normal Monster with no effect, 900 ATK / 800 DEF / Level 3 / EARTH Insect attribute (evidence.card); Appears in 2 decks (Watt 1, Hole 1) from Aug 2023, main deck only, 1 copy per deck (deck data); Zero combo appearances across supplied combo evidence (combo data.total combos = 0); Zero guide mentions (guide data.total guides = 0); Not a top card in any format (top-card data.top-card status = false)
- Observed: Appears only in old casual/legacy-format decks with generic old-card partners (Mammoth Graveyard, Silver Fang, etc.); Run as 1-of in both decks, indicating it is not a core synergy driver (deck data.copies per deck.distribution)
- Inferred: As a Level-3 EARTH Insect, usable for Synchro/XYZ/Fusion material but not optimized for modern combo lines; Bricky in opening hand; requires specific circumstance (tribute cost, synergy) to be useful; Modern Insect or tribute-based decks likely have superior body options available; The 2 decks appear to be legacy/casual formats based entirely on generic old-card partners
- Data gaps: No combos supplied — impossible to assess how it functions as starter, material, or payoff in real lines No guides — cannot confirm intended role or synergy context from author perspective No usage statistics (StatisticsCard) — archetype inclusion percentage must be inferred from 2-deck sample only Deck sample is very old (Aug 2023) and extremely small (2 decks) — limited bearing on current relevance No banlist token supplied — assumed unlimited (3 copies)






